IRC 409A

Early stage (start-up) company service offerings

By | Articles (Valuation), Valuation Services, Value Prism Consulting News | No Comments

We have packaged some of our services in highly focused and scalable engagements with high-growth early stage companies in mind.  Attached are three extremely valuable “start-up” packages currently available:

IRC 409a Valuation – You need to value common equity at fair value, says the IRS. If you raised Seed or Series A and are hiring and granting options, you need to make sure you granting the option with the strike price, not less than fair value.

Investor Pitch Integrated Finance – This is extremely important if you are raising new round of funding. You want to make sure all your number in your pitch deck make sense and that you can confidently answer the following questions: What ROI are you projecting to deliver to the investors? Is it based on sound Exit valuation? Does you pre-money valuation make sense based on Exit value and ROI? Is your Exit valuation based on your pro-forma assumptions? How solid is your TAM estimate? What market share are you forecasting at Exit?

Customer Business Case/ROI and Value Pricing – If your business model is focused on B2B you must understand and be prepared to quantify business case to your customers. What is the value proposition for your product/service to your customers? Can you quantify it? Do you have an ROI tool you can walk your customer thru that shows cost benefit analysis? How did you determine pricing for your product/service? Have you considered value pricing based on the value you are delivering? The deliverables of this package are either ROI tool OR customer facing business value selling deck OR value based pricing strategy.

Download

Please contact us at info@valueprism.com to explore if these service offerings might be a good fit for your company.

How Do I Value My Company To Grant Stock Options?

By | Articles (Valuation), Valuation Services | No Comments

Guest Post By Marek Omilian, CFA featured originally on JoeWallin.com (permalink)

Startup companies frequently have to confront this issue.  After the founder stock issuances, the company will want to be able to grant stock options to new hires.  Internal Revenue Code Section 409A requires that stock options be granted at fair market value (FMV) to avoid adverse tax consequences.

How to Determine Fair Market Value

The law does not require that companies hire an independent third party appraiser to value their stock, but it may be very helpful to you if you do.  What the law does require is that the valuation be determined by the “reasonable application of a reasonable valuation method.” The regulations state:

Factors to be considered under a reasonable valuation method include, as applicable,

  • the value of tangible and intangible assets of the corporation,
  • the present value of anticipated future cash-flows of the corporation, (i.e. DCF method)
  • the market value of stock or equity interests in similar corporations and other entities engaged in trades or businesses substantially similar to those engaged in by the corporation the stock of which is to be valued, (i.e. Comparable publicly traded companies method)
  • the value of which can be readily determined through nondiscretionary, objective means (such as through trading prices on an established securities market or an amount paid in an arm’s length private transaction),
  • recent arm’s length transactions involving the sale or transfer of such stock or equity interests, and
  • other relevant factors such as control premiums or discounts for lack of marketability and whether the valuation method is used for other purposes that have a material economic effect on the service recipient, its stockholders, or its creditors.

One should attempt use all of the above recommendations before making final conclusion. One should also reconcile different indications of value. FMV of common stock does not equal value of preferred stock in the latest round of financing or post-money valuation from the latest round. In fact, FMV of the common stock will always be lower than preferred stock because of liquidation preference given to preferred.

AICPA Practice Aid

“Valuation of Privately-Held Company Equity Securities Issued as Compensation – Accounting and Valuation Guide” commonly referred to as the “Practice Aid,” provides guidance on determining the fair market value of common stock for financial reporting requirements outlined in ASC 718 (old SFAS 123R). The same valuation satisfies the IRC 409a requirement. The Practice Aid is used by all qualified valuation professionals (hint: ask potential service provider if they follow the AICPA Practice Aid to avoid problems down the road when IRS or the auditor reviews the valuation).

In order to come up with fair market value of common equity to establish option strike price the valuation expert has to follow a two-step process:

  1. Determine Business Enterprise Value (BEV) – this is done by using discounted cash flow methodology and/or comparable transaction and/or comparable publicly traded companies approaches. Most of us are somewhat familiar with these approaches as they are the same used for any other business valuation.
  2. Allocate BEV to all of its invested capital: debt, preferred and common equity. This has to be done very carefully, as it needs to reflect all of the preference and priorities given to various classes of preferred stock. This part could be highly technical as, the leading value allocation method between preferred and common is the Option Pricing Method and involves series of option valuations.

One of the new techniques introduced in the revised Practice Aid is the concept of using the latest round of funding to “back-solve” for values of the company and its preferred and common securities. See this post for more info on using the “back-solve” approach.

Save Time and Money When Raising a New Preferred Round

By | Articles (Valuation), Valuation Services | No Comments

Guest Post By Marek Omilian, CFA featured originally on JoeWallin.com (permalink)

Commonly referred to as the “Practice Aid,” the AICPA “Valuation of Privately-Held Company Equity Securities Issued as Compensation – Accounting and Valuation Guide,” provides guidance on determining the fair market value of common stock for Section 409A purposes. This same valuation often satisfies the financial reporting requirements outlined in ASC 718. Revised back in 2013, one of the new techniques introduced in the updated Practice Aid is the concept of using the latest round of funding to “back-solve” for values of the company and its preferred and common securities.

When applied in the context of an Option Pricing Method (OPM), the technique can be used to allocate value to various rounds of Preferred and Common Stock. To reflect all of the preferences in the OPM model, a valuation expert must possess a good understanding of the method and carefully review the operating agreement of the company.

The key input for the OPM is the value of the company, which is traditionally arrived at using discounted cash flow and/or comparable companies (Market Approach). This initial step of arriving at the company value can be skipped if the company has completed a recent preferred stock financing round where a new outside investor has participated in the round. For example, if a company recently completed a Series A round of financing with a new outside investor participating at $1.00 per share, then this transaction provides good valuation evidence that the value of the Series A is $1.00. We can then solve (“goal seek”) for the total equity value input that yields Series A value of $1.00 in the OPM, given all of the other constraints and inputs in the model. We can also arrive at fair value of common stock as it is part of the OPM model. This approach is more accurate, faster, less time consuming and less costly to all involved (see table below).

IRC 409A

However, the “back-solve” can only be done (and should be done) when the round is recent. If the company passed any milestones (first customer, new version of product prototype, any new contracts with partners, patent approval, etc.) shortly after the financing round, the “back-solve” would not apply as, presumably, value of the company has changed.

In such cases, valuation expert should follow the “two-step” process:

  1. Determine value of the company using DCF and/or Market Approach.
  2. Allocation value to preferred and common using OPM or other allocation methods.